Hannah Mills Last Update:
Tuesday 25 May 2021
Hannah (Thatcher) Eastman Mills, born 21 May 1824, Hawkhurst, Kent, England, died 25 Feb 1917, Brookton NY. Second wife of Edward Hallock Mills, married 30 Dec 1896 and step-mother to Emily. Active member of Brookton Congregational Church, Ladies’ Aid Society and Women’s Christian Temperance Union. In this section, the Thatcher and Eastman genealogies are also explored.
"Mrs. Mills was one of Brookton’s oldest and most respected citizens and a remarkable woman. She enjoyed very good health, and had all her faculties up to the last. She was a great reader, and kept herself posted on all the current events and liked to converse upon them."
"She was the recipient of many tokens of love and respect, some from distant states."
Year Type Town Name Age Birthplace Occupation Industry 1865 NYS Ithaca Anna [unclear] 42 1870 US Danby Eastman Hannah 46 England 1880 US Danby Eastman Hannah 56 England Keeping home 1892 NYS Danby Hannah Eastman 68 England 1900 US Caroline Town Mills Hannah 76 England 1905 NYS Caroline Mills Hannah 87 England English House work 1910 US Caroline Town Mills Hannah 85 Eng. English None 1915 NYS Caroline Mills Hannah 91 England English House work
— United States Federal Census and New York, U.S., State Census, ancestry.com.
Click column headers to change sort order.
Download source data.
Hannah immigrated with her parents and siblings from the “Parish of Hawkhurst in the county of Kent, England”, arriving in New York City on 28 Jul 1830. Like Ellen Gould, Hannah may have retained an English accent.
Hannah’s first marriage was to Charles Eastman (05 Aug 1807 to 22 May 1890), a prominent farmer in Danby. This was Charles’ second marriage after the death of his first wife, and the mother of all of his children, Polly (Coy) Eastman (14 Feb 1808 to 03 Dec 1862).
Barbara Kone compiled information on Caroline Marriages at CarolineHistorian.org that lists Edward Mills’ marriage to Hannah and identifies Edward’s parents:
Reg. Num.: 216
Date: Dec 30, 1896
Name of Groom: MILLS, Edward H
Residence: Brookton
Age: 77
Occupation: Merchant
Place of Birth: Smithtown
Father's Name: MILLS, Jonas D
Mother's Maiden: HALLOCK (Halloch),Mary
Name Num.: 2 Marr.
Name of Bride: EASTMAN, Hannah
Married Name: Mills
Residence: Brookton
Age: 72
— Caroline Marriages The 1896 New York State Marriage Index also traces Hannah back to her maiden name, with the identfication number 25877:
Edward and Hannah joined the church just weeks before their wedding:
Dec 14 1896
At a regular Communion Service of the Congregational Church held Dec 13th The Rev Geo H Danforth officiating. Mr Edward Mills Mrs Hannah Eastman and Mrs. Arthur Green were on confession of faith served as members into the church - and the rite of Baptism was administered to the infant sons of Mr and Mrs George W Danforth and Mr and Mrs Arthur Green After which the sacrament of the lords supper was observed
George Wolcott
Clerk.
— 14 Dec 1896, Digitally photographed entry in Congregational Church 1868-1933 Minutes of Meetings and Membership , used with permission from Caroline Valley Community Church. View largest available size.
I tried to faithfully reproduce the punctuation and capitalization of the original text. Rev George Danforth was pastor from 1896 to 1898. (150th Anniversary Handbook, Caroline Valley Community Church, 16 Sep 2018.) Arthur E. Green (Sep 1860 to 16 Mar 1935)Lura A. Green (Dec 1870 to 14 Sep 1958) William B. Wolcott’s brother, George Wolcott (1836 to 1916) is the father of Reverend Clarence Reed Wolcott (1864 to 1950), who represented Edward in court on 18 Mar 1897 when Edward was accused of selling “poisonous drugs” at E. H. Mills general store in Brookton. 12-13-95 Rec.
Mr. Edward Mills
Mrs. Hannah Eastman
Mrs. Arthur Green
— 13 Dec 1895. Digitally photographed entry in Congregational Church 1868-1933 Minutes of Meetings and Membership , used with permission from Caroline Valley Community Church. View largest available size.
The date is obviously a later mis-transcription of George Wolcott’s earlier entry, where the 6 could easily be mistaken for a 5. Lura A. Green (Dec 1870 to 14 Sep 1958) Mr. E. H. Mills, our old established merchant, was married to Mrs. Hannah Eastman Dec. 30, by Rev. W. A. House. Rev. House also officiated at the wedding of Clarence Wheeler and Miss Emma English, which occurred Dec. 23. The many friends of the newly married people which them much happiness. — 07 Jan 1897, Ithaca Daily Journal, Ithaca NY, p6, nyhistoricnewspapers.org. View largest available size.
Clarence Wheeler (20 Aug 1876 to 02 Dec 1951). His obituary states that Clarence “had been engaged in well drilling in the vicinity of Brooktondale for about 55 years.” (03 Dec 1951, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p7.)Emma (English) Wheeler (27 Mar 1875 to 24 Jan 1968).Reverend William A. House lived in Brookton, was pastor at Brookton Baptist Church and performed many marriages in Brookton around this time. Mr. E. H. Mills, a former resident of this village, and a brother-in-law of the late Samuel M. Pine, was married December 30th, the bride being Mrs. Hannah Eastman. They are residents of Brookton, Tompkins county, this State.
…
MILLS—EASTMAN—At the bride’s residence in Brookton, Tompkins county, N. Y., Dec. 30th, 1896, by the Rev. W. A. House, Mr. E. H. Mills, formerly of Hempstead, and Mrs Hannah Eastman, both of Brookton.
— 14 Jan 1897, The Sentinel, Hempstead NY, p2, fultonhistory.com. View largest available size.
This image contains two separate items taken from the same page. Samuel Mills Pine (26 Nov 1814 to 14 Mar 1880)BROOKTON
Mrs. E. H. Mills who has been ill, is much better.
— 17 Dec 1908, Ithaca Daily Journal, Ithaca NY, p7, nyshistoricnewspapers.org. View largest available size.
Miss Emily Mills
Mrs. Hannah Mills
— Digitally photographed entry in Congregational Church 1868-1933 Minutes of Meetings and Membership , used with permission from Caroline Valley Community Church. View largest available size.
My impressions of Hannah are that she was an active and outgoing woman who was much loved in the community.
Mrs. Hanna Mills spent the day at the home of the Rev. Charles Bogardus. Mrs. Mills is a remarkable woman as she will be ninety years old next May. — 17 Jan 1914, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Reverend Elder Charles Bogardus (19 Nov 1843 to 12 Oct 1925). Reverend Bogardus was a Baptist minister residing in Brookton. “For 20 or more years he was pastor of five churches visiting them once each month.” (17 Oct 1925, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p5.) “He was one of the best known clergymen in this section and many couples now residing here, began their married life with his blessing. He was also called upon to officiate at many funerals. He was well-known as Elder Bogardus.” (12 Oct 1925, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p5.)Hannah’s visit with Reverend Bogardus is her last meaningful trip outside the home documented. Reverend Bogardus was also postmaster of the White Church post office, from 27 Aug 1886 to 05 Jul 1892. He later officiated Hannah’s funeral.
NINETIETH BIRTHDAY IS DULY OBSERVED
Mrs. Hannah Mills of Brookton Honored by Many Friends
Brookton, May 22.—Mrs. Hannah Mills passed her ninetieth birthday Thursday, May 21. Mrs. Mills enjoys conversing with friends and superintends her home work. The W. C. T. U. of which she is an honored member arranged a post-card shower and she received many pleasant reminders.
— 22 May 1914, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p11, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
A few months later, Hannah became ill and the first mentions of Ellen Gould as Hannah’s caretaker appear. It seems quite probable that this is an accounting of the circumstances of Ellen coming to live in the Mills’ home, to care for Emily’s elderly step-mother which Emily herself, as a business owner, would not have had adequate time to do. Ellen was presumably already well known to the Mills as she was also a member of the W.C.T.U.
Mrs. Hannah Mills is very feeble. — 26 Oct 1914, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p11, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Mrs. Ellen Gould is caring for Mrs. Hannah Mills who is still very feeble. — 31 Oct 1914, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Mrs. Tompkins of Newfield spent Friday night and Saturday with her aunt, Mrs. Hannah Mills. — 03 Nov 1914, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Mrs. Hannah Mills, who has been very ill, seems to be improving. — 07 Nov 1914, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Mrs. Hannah Mills, who has been so ill is slowly recovering. — 12 Nov 1914, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
At that time, there was a marked increase in the number of prayer and temperance meetings reported held in the Mills’ home, which is perhaps not surprising as all three women of the household were so actively involved, and this would also accommodate Hannah’s limited mobility. Hannah was clearly viewed as an important community leader to these women.
BROOKTON
Brookton, Dec. 5.—There will be preaching in the Congregational church Sunday morning. The Baptist Sunday school will meet at 12 o’clock as usual.
A cottage prayer meeting was held Thursday evening at the home of Mrs. Hannah Mills.
Harold Quick is spending the weekend in Binghamton.
William Vandemark did not move to Ithaca as he expected but concluded to stay in Brookton.
Mrs. F. B. Lounsbury who has been quite ill is improving.
Mrs. Ellen Gould attended a dinner at Caroline Depot Thursday. The dinner was given in honor of the birthday of her son, Myron Predmore, and was given by Mr. and Mrs. Kenyon.
— 05 Dec 1914, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p11, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
The Congregational meeting will be held at the home of Mrs. Hannah Mills. — 12 Jan 1915, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p11, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
BROOKTON
Brookton, Feb. 9.—The W. C. T. U. will meet with Mrs. Hannah Mills, Wednesday, 3 p.m. Refreshments will be served and a collection taken for the benefit of the local union.
— 09 Feb 1915, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
MRS. HANNAH MILLS, 91, STAUNCH W.C.T.U
Aged Woman Entertains the Union and Joins in Songs—Meeting Report
Brookton, Feb. 12.—There will be services as usual in both churches Sunday.
The W. C. T. U. met with Mrs. Hannah Mills Wednesday. Mrs. Mills is the oldest member of the union, being nearly ninety-one years old. She welcomed each member with a hearty handshake, joined in all the songs and took an active part in the meeting. The devotional exercises were conducted by Mrs. Daniel Mason. Mrs. Mulks read extracts from Billy Sunday’s famous sermon on “Booze; Or, Get on the Water Wagon.” Refreshments were served. Mrs. Simon Roe shows a decided improvement and it is hoped she will entirely regain her health.
— 12 Feb 1915, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
William Ashley “Billy” Sunday was a professional baseball player turned Presbyterian evangelist. He emphasized temperance and the cited sermon is perhaps his most famous, said to have convinced many to quit drinking. Known for being theatrical, he was one of the first preachers to make use of radio, and he was a major influence in the prohibition movement.
Mrs. Hannah Mills is suffering with a bad cold. — 22 Feb 1915, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Dr. Smith and family of Newfield motored to Brookton Monday to visit their aunt, Mrs. Hannah Mills. — 03 Mar 1915, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
THOUGH NINETY-TWO YET DOES HOUSEWORK
Friends Remember Mrs. Hannah Mills of Brookton With Birthday Tokens.
Brookton, May 23.—Mrs. Hannah Mills spent her ninety-second birthday Sunday, May 21. Mrs. Mills is still able to attend to some household duties and has a bright mind still. She was the recipient of many tokens of love and respect, some from distant states.
— 23 May 1916, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
BROOKTON ENDEAVOR SOCIETY WINS CONTEST
Brookton, Feb. 24—The contest which has been held between the Christian Endeavor Society of the Congregational Church here and the Christian Endeavor Society of the Methodist Episcopal Church in Slaterville was won by about 100 points by this society. Fifteen new members were received in the society.
Miss Amy Munson of Ithaca is visiting her uncle, Charles Personius.
Mr. and Mrs. Eugene Mitchell are visiting friends in town.
Miss Margaret Nuttall is caring for Miss Hannah Mills, who is ill.
The Sunshine class of the Congregational Sunday school met this afternoon at the home of Miss Ruth Annis to practice special music for tomorrow.
— 24 Feb 1917, The Ithaca Daily News, Ithaca NY, p2, fultonhistory.com. View largest available size.
This is the day before Hannah Mills’ death. Margaret Nuttall (09 Apr 1867, England to 22 Oct 1937)Note that like Hannah and Ellen Gould, Margaret Nuttall was born in England. Hannah died 25 Feb 1917, and her funeral was held within the Mills’ home. There is no direct indication that her death was related to the Influenza pandemic of that time.
[quite?] still 32 dg very cloudy. I am miserable all over. Very slipery. Mrs. Mills is sick. Cloudy day colder at night
Feb 20 1917
— Notebooks of George E. Jansen, Tompkins County History Center, Ithaca NY. View largest available size.
12 dg Above fair thaws some. Mrs. Mills Died today. Warmer in afternoon. Light west turning to south at night.
Feb 25 1917
— Notebooks of George E. Jansen, Tompkins County History Center, Ithaca NY. View largest available size.
On Feb 25, death invaded our midst and took one of our members, Mrs. Hannah Mills, aged 93. She had been a member of this church 20 years. — Digitally photographed entry in Congregational Church 1868-1933 Minutes of Meetings and Membership , used with permission from Caroline Valley Community Church. View largest available size.
Mrs. Hannah Eastman Mills Died Feb 25th 1917 — Digitally scanned entry in Congregational Church 1868-1933 Minutes of Meetings and Membership , used with permission from Caroline Valley Community Church. View largest available size.
OBITUARY.
Hannah Mills.
Hannah Mills, 92, died yesterday in Brookton, She leaves a stepdaughter and two stepsons. The funeral will be held at 11 o’clock Wednesday morning. Charles Bogardus will officiate,
— 25 Feb 1917, The Ithaca Daily News, Ithaca NY, p5, fultonhistory.com. View largest available size.
Hannah Mills
Mrs. Hannah Mills, aged 92 years, died yesterday at Brookton. She is survived by one step-daughter—Miss Emily Mills, Brookton; two step-sons—Cyrus Eastman, Caroline; John Eastman, Willseyville.
The funeral will be held from the late residence at 11 o’clock Wednesday morning, Elder Charles Bogardus officiating. Interment will be in the Pleasant Grove Cemetery.
— 26 Feb 1917, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p5, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Cyrus Eastman (15 May 1843 to 29 Mar 1917). According to his entry on findagrave.com “A Soldier of the Grand Army of the Republic. Cyrus Enlisted as a Private on 4 January 1864 at the age of 20 and served in Company F, 16th Heavy Artillery Regiment New York. He Mustered Out on 8 Jun 1865 at Fort Monroe, VA.”John N. Eastman (May 1835 to 24 May 1921).Reverend Elder Charles Bogardus (19 Nov 1843 to 12 Oct 1925). Reverend Bogardus was a Baptist minister residing in Brookton. “For 20 or more years he was pastor of five churches visiting them once each month.” (17 Oct 1925, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p5.) “He was one of the best known clergymen in this section and many couples now residing here, began their married life with his blessing. He was also called upon to officiate at many funerals. He was well-known as Elder Bogardus.” (12 Oct 1925, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p5.)BROOKTON
Brookton, Feb. 27.—Mrs. Hannah Mills, widow of the late E. H. Mills, died Sunday at her home in Brookton, at the advanced age of 93 years. Mrs. Mills was one of Brookton’s oldest and most respected citizens and a remarkable woman. She enjoyed very good health, and had all her faculties up to the last. She was a great reader, and kept herself posted on all the current events and liked to converse upon them. Mrs. Mills was enthusiastic in the temperance movement and a member of the W. C. T. U. and Ladies’ Aid society.
“Beautiful toiler—thy work all done;
Beautiful soul into glory gone;
Beautiful life with its crown now won;
God giveth thee rest.”
Funeral services Wednesday morning at 11 o’clock, Mr. Bogardus officiating. Burial at Pleasant Grove.
— 27 Feb 1917, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p7, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Although impossible to say with certainty, several aspects of this notice suggest to me that it could have been written by Emily. The text of the poem is the first four lines of “Rest” by Mary T. Lathrap (commonly cited as Latrhop), a nationally recognized temperance leader in the late 1800’s. According to Wikipedia : “Mary Torrans Lathrap née, Torrans; (pen name, Lena; April 25, 1838 - January 3, 1895), known as “The Daniel Webster of Prohibition”, was a 19th-century American poet, preacher, suffragist, and temperance reformer. For 20 years, she was identified with the progressive women of Michigan who had temperance, purity, and prohibition as their watchwords, and the white ribbon as their badge. A licensed preacher for the Methodist Episcopal Church (1871), she served as president of Michigan’s Woman’s Christian Temperance Union (1882), co-founded the state’s suffrage organization (1870), and worked on the amendment campaign (1874). Lathrap died in 1895.” Note the parallels to Annis Ford Eastman. This poem has been used often in obituaries since it was penned, either in part or in its entirety, and it was obviously a fitting tribute to Hannah’s life. Reverend Elder Charles Bogardus (19 Nov 1843 to 12 Oct 1925). In the 1870 census, he is a farmer in Caroline, but he later became a Baptist minister residing in Brookton. “For 20 or more years he was pastor of five churches visiting them once each month.” (17 Oct 1925, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p5.) “He was one of the best known clergymen in this section and many couples now residing here, began their married life with his blessing. He was also called upon to officiate at many funerals. He was well-known as Elder Bogardus.” (12 Oct 1925, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p5.)Notice that in the 1870 United States Federal Census, both Hannah and then husband Charles Eastman both have checks in the columns labelled “Cannot read.” and “Cannot write.”, although presumably this is inaccurate, as Hannah is described as “a great reader”.
Beautiful toiler, thy work all done,
Beautiful soul into glory gone,
Beautiful life with its crown now won,
God giveth thee rest.
Rest from all sorrows, and watching, and fears,
Rest from all possible sighing and tears,
Rest through God's endless, wonderful years —
At home with the blest.
Beautiful spirit, free from all stain,
Ours the heartache, the sorrow and pain,
Thine is the glory and infinite gain —
Thy slumber is sweet.
Peace on the brow and the eyelids so calm,
Peace in the heart, ‘neath the white folded palm,
Peace dropping down like a wondrous balm
From the head to the feet.
“It was so sudden,” our white lips said,
“How we shall miss her, the beautiful dead,
Who take the place of the precious one fled;
But Got knoweth best.
We know He watches the sparrows that fall,
Hears the sad cry of the grieved hearts that call,
Friends, husband, children, He loveth them all —
We can trust for the rest.”
— Rest by Mary T. Lathrap
Mrs. Mills funeral to day Light west winds 30 dg M Fair day cloudy A change in Wheelers milk Route Mrs Irey no better
Feb 28 1917
— Notebooks of George E. Jansen, Tompkins County History Center, Ithaca NY. View largest available size.
Ann J. Irey (? to 28 May 1917). “Mrs. J. B. Irey suffered a very severe shock of paralysis and is now in a critical condition.” (13 Feb 1917, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p7.) George Jansen, in his 1917 journal, gives regular accounts of Mrs. Irey’s condition in her final weeks (she “has got a shock” as he put it), including her last night. 07 Apr 1917 is typical: “Mrs. Irey howled all night”. And her final day, 28 May 1917: “I sat up all night with Mrs. Irey so Emeline could have a little rest. I expect her to breathe her last any minute. Respiration 30 a minute 2AM. Mrs. Irey died 1:30 PM today.” The next day, 29 May 1917: “Digging Mrs. Irey grave today.” 30 May 1917: “Mrs. Irey funeral today.”
NEWFIELD
Newfield, March 3.—Dr. William Smith and family, Mrs. Nellie Tompkins, Mrs. Edgar Thatcher attended the funeral of their aunt, Mrs. Hannah Mills of Brookton, last Monday.
Brookton
…
Dr. W. G. Smith and his family, Mrs. Monroe Tompkins, Earl Tompkins, and Edgar Thatcher of Newfield attended the funeral of their aunt, Mrs. Hannah Mills Wednesday.
— 03 Mar 1917, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p7, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Hannah’s funeral was held at the Mills’ home in Brookton, Wednesday, 28 Feb 1917.
Dr. William A. Smith (01 Feb 186? to 31 Mar 1934). Tompkins County Coroner, married to Hannah Mills’ niece, Minnie A. (Thatcher) Smith (1867 to 23 Jun 1936).
Nellie G. (Thatcher) Tompkins (1859 to 1935), wife of Monroe J. Tompkins (1856 to 1919).
Monroe Earl Tompkins (24 Jan 1897 to 07 Jun 1963), Nellie and Monroe’s son. Typically referred to as “Earl Tompkins” there are also records for him that indicate “Earl M. Tompkins”. Other children of Nellie and Monroe are Olin and Myrtle.
Edgar Thatcher.
$4,000 ESTATE GOES TO NIECES AND NEPHEWS
The $4,000 estate of Hannah Mills who died on February 25, 1917 will be divided among her nieces and nephews and George W. Townsend, of Shelburne, according to her will which was probated before Surrogate Willard M. Kent yesterday. Edward C. Thatcher and Lora E. Moat of Alpine, Nellie Tompkins and Minnie A. Smith of Newfield are the other heirs. The late Myron N. Tompkins was named executor under the will which was made 14 years ago. Surrogate Kent has appointed Edward C. Thatcher and Nellie Tompkins, administrator and administratrix with the will annexed.
— 28 Mar 1917, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p5, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
George W. Townsend, unable to identify.
Judge Willard Morrell Kent (29 Sep 1876 to 15 Jan 1958). “He was a city recorder in 1900 and from 1904 to 1910 he was the district attorney. Beginning in 1915 he served as county judge and surrogate and in 1921 he also became the judge in the Children’s Court.” (16 Jan 1958, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p3.)
Edward C. Thatcher (1863 to 04 Jun 1937), Hannah’s nephew.
Lora E. Moat. Based on a number of factors, I believe this is a mistaken reference to Sarah (Thatcher) Moot (1855 to 10 Jul 1942), Hannah’s niece.)
Nellie G. (Thatcher) Tompkins (1859 to 1935), married Monroe J. Tompkins (1856 to 1919). Monroe’s brother was Myron N. Tompkins (1859 to 21 Mar 1911), a former Dean of the Tompkins County bar and the executor of Hannah Mills’ will.
Minnie A. (Thatcher) Smith (? to 23 Jun 1936), Hannah’s niece, married to Dr. William A. Smith (01 Feb 186? to 31 Mar 1934), Tompkins County Coroner.
As one would expect, George Jansen also noted that Hannah’s step-son Cyrus Eastman died shortly after her:
3[7] dg 7AM Strong west winds light snow flurries Cyrus Eastman Died this morning. I Painted Em sink this morning Clarence Raymond & Brownie drawing wood from woods to day with two teams. I Painted inside of meat wagon this afternoon Heavy west winds in afternoon
Mar 29 1917
— Notebooks of George E. Jansen, Tompkins County History Center, Ithaca NY. View largest available size.
Em is a reference to Emma (English) Wheeler (1875-1968), wife of Clarence Wheeler (1876-1951). George writes of both often.
On 24 Mar 1917, George noted “New Proprietor meat market opens to day”. According to Gertrude Conant in her contribution to A Drive-by Tour of the Town of Caroline (Tour 4-P8), the meat market was across the street from Mills’ home at present day 470 Brooktondale Road, the Todi’s home: “‘Calf’ Charlie Vandemark had a meat market here, next to his house. It was later owned by Clarence Wheeler who also had a meat cart and went around the town selling door to door.” A photo that presumably shows Clarence standing next to a horse-drawn wagon bearing his name can be found on the bottom of page 86 of Around Caroline by Patricia A. Brhel.
Dr. and Mrs. W. A. Smith attended the burial of their aunt Mrs. Hannah Mills at Kline Cemetery last Wednesday.
— 08 May 1917, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p7, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
BROOKTON
Brookton, June 16.—The W.C.T.U. held their flower mission exercises in the Congregational Church Wednesday. In connection with the program a memorial service in tribute to the deceased members of the last year was held. They were: Mrs. Hannah Mills, who was the oldest of the 67 members; Mrs. Overacker, Miss Julia Reed and Mrs. J. B. Irey. There were 12 bouquets made and sent to sick people.
— 16 Jun 1917, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p7, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Julia E. Reed (1846 to 25 Aug 1916). “Miss Julia Reed, who has ben [sic] ill for several weeks of heart trouble, died at her home in Brookon Friday evening, August 25. Miss Reed lived the greater part of her life in this neighborhood and is a member of the Central Chapel Church. Because of her kindly and charitable disposition she leaves an unusually large circle of friends who will miss her greatly.” (01 Sep 1916, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p7.) " The funeral of Miss Julia E. Reed was very largely attended from the home of Mr. and Mrs. Melvin Lynch Monday at 2 p.m. … Mrs. Sarah Leonard spent last week at Melvin Lynch’s helping to care for her sister Miss Julia Reed." (30 Aug 1916, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p7.)
Ann J. Irey (? to 28 May 1917). “Mrs. J. B. Irey suffered a very severe shock of paralysis and is now in a critical condition.” (13 Feb 1917, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p7.) George Jansen, in his 1917 journal, gives regular accounts of Mrs. Irey’s condition in her final weeks (she “has got a shock” as he put it), including her last night. 07 Apr 1917 is typical: “Mrs. Irey howled all night”. And her final day, 28 May 1917: “I sat up all night with Mrs. Irey so Emeline could have a little rest. I expect her to breathe her last any minute. Respiration 30 a minute 2AM. Mrs. Irey died 1:30 PM today.” The next day, 29 May 1917: “Digging Mrs. Irey grave today.” 30 May 1917: “Mrs. Irey funeral today.”
Hannah is interred at Pleasant Grove Cemetery, 184 Pleasant Grove Rd, Ithaca NY 14850, in the Thatcher family plot, and is listed on the same marker as her parents, her sister, and her sister’s husband:
As with Emily, the birth year on Hannah’s grave is incorrect based on two independent sources: the 1900 United States Federal census that indicates Hannah was born “May 1824” in England:
— 13 Jun 1900, United States Federal Census, Caroline NY, p4, ancestry.com. View largest available size.
The exact date is reported in The Ithaca Journal, 23 May 1916, p9: “Mrs. Hannah Mills spent her ninety-second birthday Sunday, May 21.” Although admittedly, the wording of this does leave some room for imprecision with regard to the exact day, it at least corroborates the month and year from the 1900 census. Yet her stone lists her birth year as 1825.
As I write this in Spring 2022, the Thatcher stone is badly weathered and difficult to read, and the footstones are in even worse condition. The plot is in the front of the cemetery, the middle section, a few rows back from the road. The Thatcher name, and the side of the stone with Hannah’s parents names, faces toward the back of the cemetery, Hannah’s side faces toward Community Corners in Cayuga Heights, the Vanderveere’s side faces toward Cornell. In other words, the front of the stone is facing the back of the cemetery, the opposite of what one would expect, and inconsistent with all other stones I saw, suggesting the stone was rotated at one point.
— Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
THATCHER
— Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
It’s likely the main stone has been moved somewhat, and the footstones realigned with it. According to the Pleasant Grove Cemetery records shown below, William Vanderveere’s stone is the one that appears to missing.
Thatcher William Lot 6 Sec I
William Van DerVere
Elizabeth
Hannah
Thomas
Elizabeth
[Drawing of graves.]
— Digital photograph of record at Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
Presumably “William Thatcher” is a mistake, as is the spelling and capitalization “Van DerVere”.
The transcriptions in the following photographs have also been compared against a spreadsheet of transcribed memorials from over 100 local cemeteries, compiled over several decades by Alan Chafee, Newfield Historian, relevant portions of which he shared with me via personal correspondence, April 2022.
Thomas and Elizabeth Thatcher’s full side:
THOMAS THATCHER
BORN
July 3, 1785
DIED
June 17, 1863
ELIZABETH CROSBY,
HIS WIFE
Born Feb. 12, 1790
DIED
Mar. 29, 1873
THATCHER
— Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
THOMAS THATCHER
BORN
July 3, 1785
DIED
June 17, 1863
ELIZABETH CROSBY,
HIS WIFE
Born Feb. 12, 1790
DIED
Mar. 29, 1873
— Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
In an attempt to aid legibility, I have provided the original digital photographs taken April 2022, along with modified versions in grayscale with enhanced contrast.
Thomas Thatcher’s portion:
Elizabeth (Crosby) Thatcher’s portion:
ELIZABETH CROSBY,
HIS WIFE
Born Feb. 12, 1790
DIED
Mar. 29, 1873
— Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
ELIZABETH CROSBY,
HIS WIFE
Born Feb. 12, 1790
DIED
Mar. 29, 1873
— Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
William and Elizabeth Vanderveere’s full side:
[unclear, but identifies William P. Vanderveere]
BORN
Sept. 4, 1831
DIED
May 27, 1882
ELIZABETH
HIS WIFE
1829-1888
— Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
William P. Vanderveere’s portion:
[unclear, but identifies William P. Vanderveere]
BORN
Sept. 4, 1831
DIED
May 27, 1882
— Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
[unclear, but identifies William P. Vanderveere]
BORN
Sept. 4, 1831
DIED
May 27, 1882
— Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
Elizabeth Vanderveere:
The following images from 2016 are much clearer:
WILLIAM P. VANDERVEERE
BORN
Sept. 4, 1831
DIED
May 27, 1882
ELIZABETH
HIS WIFE
1829-1888
— Jul 2016, Don Short. Originally published on findagrave.com, republished here with permission from Don Short, personal correspondence, 24 May 2022. View largest available size.
ELIZABETH
HIS WIFE
1829-1888
— Jul 2016, Don Short. Originally published on findagrave.com, republished here with permission from Don Short, personal correspondence, 24 May 2022. View largest available size.
The 2016 photos show the “MOTHER” footstone leaning against the main family stone, confirming that the stones have been moved in the past. In fact, because these photos are close-up, the direction of the camera and therefore, the orientation of the main stone, is not clear, and the main stone itself may have been turned. (As I write this, the main stone faces the rear of the cemetery, away from the road.)
Hannah (Thatcher) Mills:
HANNAH MILLS
THEIR DAUGHTER
1825 - 1917
— Pleasant Grove Cemetery, Ithaca NY, taken April 2022. View largest available size.
“Hannah Thatcher Mills” is buried in Pleasant Grove Cemetery with her parents, Thomas and Elizabeth (Crosby)Thatcher. Her stone identifies her as the daughter of Thomas and Elizabeth Thatcher. Their names are on the same marker and it is in the front of the cemetery in what I identified as section one and her marker is the fourth one in from the north and in the third row in from the east. The dates on Hannah’s marker for her are 1825 - 1917. Thomas Thatcher’s dates are July 3, 1785 - June 17, 1863 and his wife, Elizabeth Crosby Thatcher are Feb. 12, 1790 - Mar. 29, 1873. The names and dates for William P. and Elizabeth Vanderveere are also on the same Thatcher marker. Their dates are William P. Vanderveere, Sept. 4, 1831 - May 27, 1882 and his wife Elizabeth Vanderveere, 1829 - 1888. The marker states that she is William P.’s wife.
I have made a spreadsheet containing all of the names that I have found in over 100 local cemeteries and I have only found the names for 5 other Mills and they are in the Curtis Cemetery in Danby and the Ithaca City Cemetery.
— 22 Apr 2022, Alan Chaffee, personal correspondence.
A copy of the spreadsheet mentioned above is on file with the Tompkins County Clerk’s Office in Ithaca NY.
The Thatchers
Hannah’s parents:
Hannah’s siblings:
Currently unknown:
Edgar Thatcher. I initially thought this was a mistaken reference to Edward Thatcher, and that is still a possibility, but I have seen this name referenced in a few places, so perhaps not. I have been unable to identify this person.
Silas Thatcher, a “farm laborer” listed in the 1850 federal census living with the Thatcher family, and in the 1860 federal census was living with a family by the name Fleming. He also indicates England is his origin, and given his age, he is likely Thomas Thatcher’s brother. (A possible daughter: Sarah C. (Thatcher) O’Brien .)
Both the Thatchers and the Tompkins families are associated with the towns of Newfield and Catharine, with Edward living in Cayutaville, and a few descendants living in Ithaca.
Hannah’s immigration information is based on naturalization documents of her brother David Thatcher from 1839, that are on still on file with the Tompkins County Clerk’s Office. I conclude this document identifies Hannah Mills’ brother based on the document matching several known data points: first and last name, town of residence, age, country of origin, and the voyage happened within the expected timeframe. As a result, I am also using this document as the source for David’s exact birthdate, as prior to seeing this, I only knew the year.
— 02 Oct 1839, David Thatcher Naturalization, p2, Tompkins County Clerk. View largest available size.
— 02 Oct 1839, David Thatcher Naturalization, p3, Tompkins County Clerk. View largest available size.
Elizabeth Vanderveere appears to be Hannah’s sister, based on the following data points:
The 16 Oct 1850 United States Federal census shows the Thatcher family in Newfield with a 21 year old woman named Elizabeth. The age and birthplace are consistent with this being the Thomas and Elizabeth’s daughter, and matches the age of Elizabeth Vanderveere.
The 01 Jun 1865 New York State Census shows Hannah and Charles Eastman living with 36 year old Elizabeth Thatcher, identified as “sister in law” and 75 year old Elizabeth Thatcher identified as “mother in law”.
The 04 Aug 1870 United States Federal census shows William and Elizabeth Vanderveere living with the widowed Elizabeth (Crosby) Thatcher. Both Elizabeth Thatcher and Elizabeth Vanderveere list England as their birthplace.
And obviously, the Vanderveere’s are buried in the Thatcher family plot.
— 10 Oct 1850, United States Federal Census, Newfield NY, p72, ancestry.com. View largest available size.
— 01 Jun 1865, New York State Census, Ithaca NY, p680-681, ancestry.com. View largest available size.
— 04 Aug 1870, United States Federal Census, Ithaca NY, p252, ancestry.com. View largest available size.
Sometime between 1850 and 1855, David Thatcher married Agnes Tannahill, and along with his parents, moved to Catharine NY.
— 19 Jun 1855, New York State Census, Catharine NY, ancestry.com. View largest available size.
And the 1860 federal census shows William Vanderveere working as a farm laborer in Dryden.
— 24 Jul 1860, United States Federal Census, Dryden NY, p79, ancestry.com. View largest available size.
Myron N. Tompkins Dead.
Ithaca, March 21.—Myron N. Tompkins, dean of the Tompkins county bar, died this morning of Bright’s disease. He was 6[?] years of age and was the best known lawyer in this part of the state. He was the city’s first recorder and represented the Lehigh Valley Railroad and other large corporations. H was at the time of his death conducting the case of the village of Waverly, in its fight for municipal ownership of its water supply system.
— 22 Mar 1911, The Democrat And Chronicle, Rochester NY, p8, nyshistoricnewspapers.org. View largest available size.
Myron N. Tompkins (1859 to 21 Mar 1911).
“Bright’s disease is a historical classification of kidney diseases that are described in modern medicine as acute or chronic nephritis. It was characterized by swelling and the presence of albumin in the urine, and was frequently accompanied by high blood pressure and heart disease. …It is now known that Bright’s disease is caused by a wide and diverse range of kidney diseases; thus, the term Bright’s disease is retained strictly for historical application. The disease was diagnosed frequently in diabetic patients; at least some of these cases would probably correspond to a modern diagnosis of diabetic nephropathy.” (Bright’s Disease , Wikipedia.org.)
Monroe Tompkins
Monroe Tompkins, 63, died Saturday afternoon at his home one mile south of Newfield. Besides his wife he leaves a daughter, Mrs. William Talbot of Elmira; two sons, Olin and Earl Tompkins of Newfield; a brother, Elmer Tompkins of Ludlowville.
The funeral, which was private, was held at 2 o’clock this afternoon from the home. Rev. J. W. Wilson officiated. Burial was in Woodlawn Cemetery.
— 13 Jan 1919, Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p5, nyshistoricnewspapers.org. View largest available size.
Dr. Smith, 67, Coroner Here 17 Years, Dies
First Took Office Jan. 1, 1916—Was Health Officer of Town of Newfield for 25 Years—Health Began to Fail About 8 Years Ago
Dr. William A. Smith, 67, coroner of Tompkins County since Jan. 1, 1916, and for many years before that health officer of the Town of Newfield, died at his home, 308 Lake Avenue at 10 o’clock Saturday night, Mar. 31, following a [l]ong illness.
Doctor Smith was born at Catherine[sic] Schuyler County, on Feb. 1, 186[?] and graduated from the Dundee High School. He studied medicine for two years at the University of Michigan and later attended the Long Island Hospital College from which he graduated in 1889.
After graduation, Doctor Smith began practice at Geneva. Six years later he moved to Newfield where he practiced for 35 years. During 25 years of that time he served as health officer.
Doctor Smith became a Republican candidate for the office of county coroner in the fall of 1915 and was elected over Dr. A. A. Chase. His term was for three years and he was re-elected at every election since, on several occasions having the Democratic endorsement as well as the Republican. He was re-elected last year over Dr. M. J. Foran.
Underwent Operation
Eight years ago Doctor Smith’s health began to fail and he went to New York where he underwent a major operation. The operation was successful and he had been in good health until about a year ago when he removed to Ithaca.
Besides his widow, Doctor Smith is survived by two daughters, Mrs. Agnes Shulman of Ithaca and Mrs. Alliene Esterbrook of Newfield; seven grandchildren of Newfield; his mother, Mrs. Olive A. Smith of Odessa and one sister, Mrs. Clarence Hausner of Odessa.
Private funeral services will be held at the family home, 308 Lake Avenue, at 2 o’clock Wednesday afternoon, Apr. 4. The Rev. Henry P. Horton, rector of St. John’s Episcopal Church, will officiate. Interment will be in Laurel Cemetery at Odessa.
Doctor Smith was a past master of King Hiram, Lodge, F. and A. Masons of Newfield.
— 02 Apr 1934, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p3, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Dr. W. A. Smith's full name was Dr. William Addison Smith and he lived up South St., now called Shaffer Rd. on the right I think a short distance behind the Tioga State Bank. I know his full name as I remember the old folks calling him William Addison Smith. He and his wife, Minnie A. are buried over in the Laurel Hill Cemetery east of Odessa in the Town of Catharine. His stone reads William A. Smith, M. D., blank - 1934. His wife Minnie A. reads, blank - 1936 and Anna E. Smith 1877 - 1960. Anna's grave marker is right next to the grave marker for Dr. Smith and his wife Minnie. ...Dr. William Addison Smith's father was George Addison Smith, 1835 - 1911 who is also buried in Laurel Hill Cemetery over in the Town of Catharine
— 22 Apr 2022, Alan Chaffee, personal correspondence.
Deaths and funerals
Mrs. Nellie T. Tompkins
Mrs. Nellie T. Tompkins died Thursday morning, May 30, 1935, at his home [sic], one mile south of Newfield, where funeral services will be held at 2 o’clock Saturday afternoon. The Rev. O. D. Steward, pastor of the Methodist Church, will officiate. Burial will be in Woodlawn Cemetery.
Mrs. Tompkins was a member of Newfield Grange for many years. She was the widow of Monroe Tompkins.
Surviving are two sons, Olin and Earl Tompkins of Newfield; a daughter, Mrs. Myrtle Talbett of Binghamton; two sisters, Mrs. Sara Moot of Cayutaville and Mrs. Minnie Smith of Ithaca, and a brother, Edward Thatcher of Cayutaville.
— 31 May 1935, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p7, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Deaths and funerals
Mrs. Minnie A. Smith
Mrs. Minnie A. Smith, 69, widow of Coroner William A. Smith, died at her home, 308 Lake Avenue, Tuesday, June 23, 1936. She had been ill only a short time.
She is survived by two daughters, Mrs. Agnes Shulman of Ithaca and Mrs. Alleine Estabrook of Newfield; a sister, Mrs. Sara Moot and a brother, Edward Thatcher, both of Cayutaville. Also seven grandchildren and several nieces and nephews.
Private services will be held at the family home at 2 p. m. Friday. The Rev. Henry P. Horton, rector of the St. John’s Episcopal Church, will officiate. Interment will be in Laurel Hill Cemetery in Odessa.
— 24 Jun 1936, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY , p5, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Edward C. Thatcher
Edward C. Thatcher, 74, died at his home at 5:45 p. m. Friday, June 4, 1937, in Cayutaville.
He is survived by his widow, one sister, Mrs. Sara Moot, and several nieces and nephews, all of Cayutaville.
Funeral services will be held at 2:30 p. m. Monday in Lawrence Chapel on Cayuta Lake, the Rev Asa A. Nichols officiating. Burial will be in Laurel Hill Cemetery.
— 05 Jun 1937, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p9, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Arthur Rogers is visiting Mr. and Mrs. Austin King of Buffalo.—Mrs. Sarah Moot, a lifelong resident, passed away Friday afternoon at the home of her son, Ed. Moot, where she resided. The funeral was held from the Stone Chapel on Kayuta Lake, where Mrs. Moot attended church years ago.
— 15 Jul 1942, Star Gazette, Elmira NY, p15, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
MONROE E. TOMPKINS
NEWFIELD—Monroe Earl Tompkins, 66, of the South Hill Road, died at his residence Friday evening.
He was the son of Monroe and Millie Thatcher Tompkins and a life resident of the community. Mr. Tompkins was a retired farmer.
Surviving are: his wife, Mrs. Minnie Wademan Tompkins; a son, Lloyd; a daughter, Miss Marcella Tompkins; a brother, Olin, all of Newfield, and a sister, Mrs. William Talbott of Elmira.
Services will be at 2 p.m. Monday at the Gilbert Memorial Home, Ithaca, with the Rev. Jack Kissel, pastor of the Newfield Methodist Church, officiating. Burial will be in Woodlawn Cemetery.
Friends may call Sunday evening at the funeral home.
— 09 Jun 1963, The Post Standard, Syracuse NY, p106, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
Monroe E. Tompkins
NEWFIELD—Monroe Earl Tompkins, retired farmer and lifelong resident of Newfield, died Friday afternoon, June 7, 1963, at his home on South Hill Rd.
He was born Jan 24, 1897, in Newfield, the son of Nellie J. Thatcher and Monroe Tompkins of Newfield.
Surviving are his wife, Minnie Wademan Tompkins; a son, Lloyd of Newfield; a daughter, Marcella of Newfield; a brother, Olin, of Newfield; and a sister, Mrs. William Talbott of Elmira.
Funeral services were held at 2 p.m. today in the Gilbert Memorial Home, 602 W. State St. The Rev. Jack Kissell of the Newfield Methodist Church officiated.
— 10 Jun 1963, The Ithaca Journal, Ithaca NY, p2, newspapers.com. View largest available size.
I have contacted several living descendants of David Thatcher, and Joan Taber of Newfield appears to be the one with the greatest knowledge of the family history, having preserved many artifacts and performed her own research over the years. At one time, she thought she may have had a photo of David Thatcher, and she also believes she has some Eastman materials. According to Joan and another descendant, there are family anecdotes about Thomas Thatcher ringing the church bells in England, and there are references in their documents to a “Mercy Thatcher” although nobody seems to know who this person might be exactly.
The Eastmans
Charles Eastman had a daughter Hannah (Eastman) Meaker (15 May 1843 to 20 Dec 1881), who appears to be Cyrus’ twin sister and wife of George M. Meaker. George M. Meaker’s parents are Reuben E. Meaker (1823 to 09 Jun 1894) and Elsie (Briggs) Meaker (1824 to 09 Mar 1893). Hannah and George’s children include two daughters, Mamie Elsie (Meaker) Crance (15 Jan 1873 to 13 Oct 1955) and Ida Adelia (Meaker) Husted (21 Jul 1878 to 08 Jul 1958)
There is another Hannah Eastman in Caroline at this time: Hannah V. (Smith) Eastman (1826 to 05 Feb 1892) who was married to Reuben B. Eastman (Jun 1829 to 15 Nov 1913), Charles C. Eastman’s brother.
Charles C. Eastman had a son Charles Henry Eastman , so references to “Mrs. Charles Eastman” may also need to be disambiguated. As evidenced by the deeds below, Charles Henry Eastman’s family moved from Danby to Michigan by 1891.
All that in mind, I believe all of the deeds that follow are referencing Hannah Mills:
REAL ESTATE TRANSFERS,
FOR THE WEEK ENDING July 18.
…
DANBY.
John N. Eastman to Hannah Eastman, 81 1/[2?] acres, lots 3 and 4, $500.
…
— 19 Jul 1876, Ithaca Daily Journal, Ithaca NY, p4, nyshistoricnewspapers.org. View largest available size.
— 05 Apr 1876, John N. Eastman to Hannah Eastman, Danby Deeds Book 2, p442, Tompkins County Clerk, Ithaca NY. View largest available size.
— 13 Jul 1876, John N. Eastman to Hannah Eastman, Danby Deeds Book 2, p443, Tompkins County Clerk, Ithaca NY. View largest available size.
— 30 Sep 1891, Charles Henry Eastman (etal) to Hannah Eastman, Deeds Book 135, p453, Tompkins County Clerk, Ithaca NY. View largest available size.
— 14 Jun 1890, Will of Charles C. Eastman, Deeds Book 136, p516, Tompkins County Clerk, Ithaca NY. View largest available size.
— 14 Jun 1890, Will of Charles C. Eastman, Deeds Book 136, p517, Tompkins County Clerk, Ithaca NY. View largest available size.
…The following estates have been judicially settled:
Charles Labar, late of Dryden.
Francis A. Bates, late of Caroline.
Floretta B. Smith, late of Groton.
Eliza O. Hazen, late of Ithaca.
David B. Torrey, late of Caroline.
Jared S. Halsey, late of Ulysses.
Charles C. Eastman, late of Caroline.
— 30 Sep 1891, Ithaca Daily Journal, Ithaca NY, p3, nyshistoricnewspapers.org.. View largest available size.
— 08 Mar 1892, Hannah Eastman to Frank W. Hurd, Deeds Book 139, p88, Tompkins County Clerk, Ithaca NY. View largest available size.
I have contacted one descendant of Charles C. and Polly Eastman, Jodi Leaf, and she is the most knowledgable Eastman family historian, having done much of her own research, and contributing genealogies, photos, etc. to findagrave.com and ancestry.com. Numerous family photos exist starting with the children of Charles C. and Polly Eastman.